Main
Thursday
Feb032011

"God Bless You, Kim Jong"

Publisher: The Fanzine
Date: 08.07.06
Article Link



A couple weeks ago, I made fun of George W. Bush for claiming after North Korea’s failed Taepo Dong-2 missile test, that the United States had a “reasonable chance” of shooting said missile down—mostly because it seemed pretty ludicrous to me to boast about our ability to intercept a long-range intercontinental ballistic missile days after we knew it had already failed two minutes after its launch. It was a statement that necessitated a few qualifiers for Bush—among them, “at least that’s what the military commander has told me”—because selling the argument for rekindling missile defense required his audience to buy into a hypothetical situation: that we could have shot down the missile had it come within proximity of United States borders.

Of course, this didn’t happen. The Taepo Dong-2 missile, which was designed to test what U.S. intelligence believes to be a 3-stage ICBM with a range of 3,000-3,700 miles, didn’t make it past its initial booster phase. Technically speaking, the Taepo Dong-2 could reach Hawaii and Alaska. But more important was the symbolic nature of the test—not just for its July 4th launch, but for the psychological boost it gave to both the Great Leader in tormenting his arch nemesis, and to missile defense proponents in the United States. As Lt. General Robert Gard and John D. Isaacs wrote on the Web site for the Center for Arms Control and Non-Proliferation: “These events represent a symmetrical international Kabuki dance: the North Koreans tested a missile with no idea whether or not it would function as intended, and the United States activated a missile defense system without evidence that it has the capability to intercept the North Korean missile.” And even more revealing of the symbiotic nature between NMD proponents and countries like North Korea is a quote from Donald Rumsfeld after the launch of the original Taepo Dong missile in 1998, “God bless you, Kim Jong.”

Kim Jong Il’s behavioral patterns aren’t unpredictable. The megalomaniacal dictator’s strident cries for attention are usually metered out when the world’s news focus is elsewhere. And it works, with a huge impact. If Kim Jong Il was half as good at feeding his country, the Taepo Dong-2 might have flown another five minutes (a joke seized upon by political cartoonists). The failure of the launch actually means very little for North Korea because Kim has the United States eating out of his hand, so to speak (a bad, unintended pun, I know). This isn’t to say I think North Korea has no intentions of improving its ICMBs, but more than anything, Kim sells fear; he remains obstinate in global politics and knows the U.S. is too mired in its own shitstorms in Iraq and Afghanistan (does anyone remember we’re still looking for Osama bin Laden there?) to make any military move against it, and he plays directly to the music of U.S. intelligence and defensive policy: the it could happen criteria.

This all seems pretty familiar. Just weeks before the first Taepo Dong launch, the Rumsfeld Commission released its July 1998 report that refuted findings in a National Intelligence Estimate three years earlier that said threats of missile attacks from a rogue nation like North Korea were at least 15 years off. The Rumsfeld Commission’s report was significant not only in defining a “discernable” (i.e. post-Soviet) threat by missile attack, but also, somewhat indirectly, in redefining in their own terms the standards on which national intelligence was, and would be, based. Previously the intelligence community focused on threats they considered likely events; after the Taepo Dong launch, they were forced to accept the Rumsfeld Commission’s much broader standard of what plausibly could happen. Oh, those crafty Republicans.

With such wide-open criteria, the Rumsfeld Commission’s report, combined with the Taepo Dong launch, set the stage for NMD advocates like Paul Wolfowitz, Trent Lott, Newt Gingrich, and Rumsfeld himself, to push an extremely expensive project that has produced very limited results at best in its 50 years in development—and the Taepo Dong-2 launch appears capable of doing the same. Politicians leaped upon the Commission’s findings as proof of a concrete threat that necessitated billions of dollars of investment—threats not only based on the aforementioned looser standard of chance, but findings Dr. Richard Garwin, the Commission’s own (and only) physicist described to Frontline as thus: “We did the best we could with our limited charter. We said, ‘Yes, indeed there are countries that could, within five years, if they had a well-funded program and external support from missile powers and high priority on their program, they could have an ICBM which would be unreliable, inaccurate, and very few.’”

From 1985 to 2004, the United States has spent nearly $65 billion in developing a national missile defense. From 2004 to 2009, the projected budget is expected to require another $58 billion. The NMD budget item for 2007 is set at $10.4 billion. Since taking office, Bush has consistently requested nearly $10 billion in budget allocations toward NMD projects—all the while taking fire for pushing a political, rather than a technology-based schedule. Past incarnations of national missile defense in the United States have been the Nike-Zeus project in the 1950s, Project Defender in the 1960s, Robert McNamara’s Sentinel Program in 1967, and a scaled-down version, also in the late-1960s, called the Safeguard Program. All of the programs were highly theoretical and faced daunting and numerous obstacles of a technological nature. They also created a moral quandary (the idea of intercepting and exploding a nuclear-tipped ICBM in a friendly country’s atmosphere was not highly desirable). There was also the problem of jeopardizing the doctrine of Mutually Assured Destruction, a deterrent-theory based around the idea that if a country like Soviet Russia attacked the United States, the retaliatory nuclear strike would devastate their cities as bad as ours. But if a country could defend itself from nuclear attacks, nuclear saber rattling could quickly escalate to arbitrary extinction of rival nations.

NMDs at this time came in a variety of solutions, from intercepting ICBMs with nuclear missiles of our own, to orbiting satellites that would fire missiles that could deploy large mesh nets stopping the attack in the boost phase of the launch and presumably send it plummeting back to earth to meet its maker (most likely Soviet Russia). Further research showed intercepting missiles of a kinetic (non-explosive, akin to a bullet) type to be more useful, and indeed the U.S. has successfully tested hit-to-kill, defensive rockets like these in recent years.

The 1972 Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty and its revision in 1974 allowed the two major Cold War players to each deploy a single ABM system within its own borders. The Soviets built its A-35 system around Moscow, and it’s still functional today under an improved A-135 system. In a decision that really doesn’t seem that weird anymore, the United States chose to protect its missile cache at the Grand Forks Air Force Base in North Dakota with Project Safeguard. Like the Soviet system, Safeguard utilized nuclear-tipped missiles to intercept enemy warheads. The Stanley R. Mickelson Safeguard Complex was built in 1975 and reached initial operating capability in April of the same year. On October 1, 1975 the site reached maximum capability, housing 100 interceptors, the maximum allowed under the ABM treaty. Safeguard, however, was mostly an illusion of defense—the Pentagon warned that the Soviets easily had enough nuclear ammunition to overwhelm the defenses, and in a secret memo to President Nixon, Secretary of State Henry Kissinger said Safeguard’s main contractor had no faith in the system. One day after reaching full capability, Congress voted to shut it down. Safeguard was the culmination of 20 years of research and development, and it lasted less than eight months and cost $25 billion.

In 1983, President Ronald Reagan introduced the Strategic Defense Initiative, which quickly became better known and derided as “Star Wars.” The Star Wars system aimed to shoot down nuclear missiles via nuclear-powered X-rays fired from space-based battle satellites, coupled with new control systems and ground-based defenses. Unlike previous theories of missile defense like Safeguard, which focused on limited-area defenses, SDI was to provide total coverage from full-scale nuclear attacks. Reagan’s program presented a twist on the Mutually Assured Destruction theory and instead boldly suggested that once the SDI was complete and perfected, would be shared with our Cold War nemesis. SDI would cost more than $44 billion over its 10 years of development, and obviously never fully advanced past this stage towards its very ambitious goals.

National missile defense is currently known in the United States as the Ground-Based Midcourse Defense, or GMD. The designation was updated in December 2001 after Bush decided to remove the United States from “the constraints” of the ABM Treaty, much in the same unilateral vein that seems to be this administration’s trademark, i.e. the Kyoto Accord and certain details of the Geneva Convention. (Actually, Bush laid the groundwork for this move in May 2001, but September 11 pretty much sealed the deal.) Currently we have limited ground-based missile defenses deployed in Alaska, and several hit-to-kill tests have been successful against mock ICBMs, as recently as February 2005. We still haven’t given up on the Gipper’s vision of lasers blasting nuclear warheads out of the sky like a game of Asteroids. Air-based laser systems are still in development, with vehicles ranging from satellites to B-2 bombers. The reality of this technology, however, is still pretty limited to a contractor’s computer animation and an artist's renditions. More realistically, the GMD will expand deployment areas to Europe and incorporate naval defenses and computer technology into one encompassing system.

September 11 ushered in a new kind of world for the United States. On the one hand, it made it very clear what some countries think of us, an image we arguably haven’t much improved on since, and on the other hand gave the Bush administration free reign to do as they pleased in the name of national defense. And they sold it brilliantly—Bush and NMD advocates have repeatedly used September 11 as an example of why we need a missile defense shield, despite the fact that even in 1995, the NIE report which the Rumsfeld Commission was charged with refuting, stated that the likelihood of unconventional terrorist-type actions clearly outweighed the threat of an outright nuclear attack. And yet we’re as obstinate as Kim Jong Il is bent on flouting the rules of international nuclear armament, sinking hundreds of billions of dollars on a technology that we don’t have or possess, striving for a system that for the last 50 years has produced lots of very ambitious ideas and a few working models at best. It’s a thin layer of comfort and safety, and while North Korea may very well be working on improving their Taepo Dong-2 ICBM, it’s years from production and the potential threat of selling to another rogue nation one of possibly eight nuclear warheads already known to be in their possession is, in fact, very real.

So we can watch Bush swagger like a bemused cowboy and sell us the necessity of missile defense, experimental technology with a long history of failure and a few dubious successes that we’re supposed to trust will save us from nuclear attack. The total for technological onanism comes to $100 million per test—building up national missile defense for its own sake and lining defense contractors’ pockets for their CGI videos, when everyone knows it’s much easier, and precedented, for people to fly a plane into a building or detonate a bomb—even a dirty bomb—on a crowded train than it is to build a nuclear-armed ICBM. We might not want the smoking gun to be in the shape of a mushroom cloud, but if we knew it was coming could we pretend to stop it? 

References (65)

References allow you to track sources for this article, as well as articles that were written in response to this article.
  • Response
    Any ideas of what I can write about? What would you be interested in reading? And how can I get people to see it?.
  • Response
    Response: vets
    What's the best way to copyright a website and all its contents? Copyright poetry?
  • Response
    Response: organic seo
    I want to start a fashion blog but have no idea where to start?
  • Response
    How can I get Firefox to save a webpage from the local files, rather than downloading it from the Internet?
  • Response
    i need some ideas for a blog. i already do poems and surveys on it but i wanna talk about something..
  • Response
    Response: posicionar web
    Hi I'm interested in computer courses to study, today I spoke to someone from one of the unis I was interested in one of the courses were more about designing and the other practical and more technical fixing and support the system. I'm really interested in that. Its called computer enterprising. ...
  • Response
    I am 15 and I want to start a fashion blog. What should I call it? Also, please tell me any tips you have for getting started and what I could do on it or how to do it..
  • Response
    I have a web page for my business and there is a link to my blog on it, it want to show the blog posts on the webpage not just the link and I can't figure out how to do it. Any help would be appreciated.
  • Response
    Response: repair a roof
    Does everyone like blogspot or is there a better way to go?
  • Response
    I have a website idea that i know will make me money, i just don't know what to do and where to start..
  • Response
    Any recomendations on how to start a blog for teens?
  • Response
    Response: check
    How can I add a link to my website from a Joomla website?
  • Response
    Response: medical insurance
    If I start a blog on Myspace, will it get listed in search engines like Google? If so, is there a way to keep them from being crawled?. . Thank you.
  • Response
    I'm new to blogspot and I'm having a difficult time. How can I change the background to a picture I want?.
  • Response
    Response: [source]
    I have a degree in psychology, which I have found to be useless. And I am planning on going back to school and getting a Masters in Creative Writing, because I enjoy writing and would love to learn more techniques to make myself a better writer. I am worried, however, that ...
  • Response
    Response: home insurance
    Where can i get hindu religious Joomla templates for hindu temples ?
  • Response
    Response: coverage
    How do I get blog stats widget on my new wp blog?
  • Response
    Response: discover here
    I got two networked blog setting of a single blog in facebook. I want to delete of them. Is there any way to delete only one networked blog keeping the another as it is ?.
  • Response
    Response: find out here now
    im pretty good with Dreamweaver so i know how to design the site, but i dont know which site would get alot of attention... i want either a Hip Hop site with news, board and etc.. or A youtube like site... or a porn site.. my main interest is making money ...
  • Response
    see here for top quality glossary work available
  • Response
    How do I make my own Blogger layout? I already made a header, I want to learn how to make a matching layout?
  • Response
    Response: see page
    How can I change the settings in Thunderbird so that I choose the e-mail address used to forward blog posts?
  • Response
    Does anyone know of a good site offering tutorials in customising blogspot/blogger skins? I'm a total novice who doesn't know anything about HTML. Help!.
  • Response
    Response: more helpful hints
    Blogspot Question: How can I make my current blog appear on my personal webpage?
  • Response
    Response: try these out
    How can creative writing be taught in a standardized way?
  • Response
    Response: view it now
    How do I easily integrate my wordpress blog on my Joomla site?
  • Response
    ^. . Background: I'm applying for an MFA in creative writing program, and I've never taken a creative writing course. Most of my creative writing knowledge comes from research I did on my own. I'm wondering if during my research I at least learned the basics of creative writing, or if ...
  • Response
    What computer brands allow you to build your own computer?
  • Response
    Response: official statement
    Is there a copyright or anything on content in Youtube videos?
  • Response
    Response: house
    Is this possible? I am following two Blogspot accounts using my Twitter account. But when I look at my Twitter news feed, I never see updates from either of these Blogspots (and they have been updated). Is there a setting I need to change, or is this not even possible to ...
  • Response
    Where are some good places to get good free blogger templates?
  • Response
    I have about 4-5 sites that are outdated and not used. I have a new blog @ blogspot and I would like to forward those domains so they show up on the blogspot address. How do I go about doing this? My domains are hosted by GoDaddy and are blank at ...
  • Response
    Response: coverage
    Hi there. I was just wondering why its such a big thing these days to have a ridiculous amount of ram in a computer? People tell me that the more Ram you have in your computer the faster your computer will be. I always thought that it was the processor that ...
  • Response
    What resources are available to anyone wanting to set up a creative writing course?
  • Response
    Response: what is it worth
    can anyone give me copyright guidelines pertaining to getting articles from other sites.?
  • Response
    Response: this contact form
    Why does Alex Jones just post mainstream news articles on his website? Isn't he breaking copyright laws?
  • Response
    see here for top quality prevent arthritis in dogs around
  • Response
    Creative writing copywright: How to protect work when submitting to potential publishers or literary agents?
  • Response
    Response: build backlinks
    I want to add a registration form to Joomla.. . I need to be able to edit the fields of the form. . The form needs to register people as users in Joomla, and trigger an HTML welcome email, as well as a notification to an admin about the registration.. . ...
  • Response
    Response: car insurance
    I want to make my own Blogger layout because none of the ones I have found incorporate my Header correctly/match with my Header that I want to use. Is there a website that can teach me how to do this? (I also do not have Photoshop, so I need to use ...
  • Response
    Response: see here
    How to start a blog. Kindly suggest books on the subject?
  • Response
    What happens to files when my wordpress space upgrade expires?
  • Response
    Is a Wordpress or Blogspot a better place to host your blog?
  • Response
    Hi. I have a blog which i installed wordpress. So far so good. Except that wordpress stats shows me the visits and i want it to show how many visitors visited my blog. Can anyone help me? Thanks a lot..
  • Response
    I'm working on company shopping website that uses joomla as its server (if that's the correct word). . Someone uploaded files with spaces and apostrophes in the wrong folder and Joomla won't let me delete them in the usual way.. . How can I delete these files (or edit the file ...
  • Response
    Response: great site
    How to get FireFox or any browser up first on reboot?
  • Response
    Response: terrycloth robe
    Where can i get hindu religious Joomla templates for hindu temples ?
  • Response
    What hosting sites will allow my blog to make money off adds being placed on my blog?
  • Response
    click here for greatest glucosamine for dogs anywhere
  • Response
    see here for greatest posicionamiento seo available
  • Response
    Response: dogs arthritis
    get greatest treatment for arthritis available
  • Response
    Is there a degree that exists for use of music AND creative writing two fields? If there is, do you know the name of it?. . I want to combine these two of my interests (loves) but I don't know what kind of degree offers the use of both.. . Please ...
  • Response
    I use a micro SD card between my laptop and netbook as an external hardrive for my class files. I often download files on one computer or the other without the drive in that computer. Is it possible to set my computer up so that when I insert my drive my ...
  • Response
    Response: wood windows
    I have a business blog through which I offer certain goods and services. It is also a general-information blog, however. I am seeking to move it to another blog host. I know that blogspot offers user-sponsored advertising, but are there any other free blogs that allow something like blogspot's adsense and/or ...
  • Response
    I want to switch to a clean new WordPress theme for a site, but Google has indexed 2500 pages from the old site (mainly due to a calendar module creating a new page for each day). How do I ensure all those pages remain accessible for Google, without throwing up a ...
  • Response
    How can I insert a tag cloud into my blog @ blogspot?
  • Response
    Response: french homes
    Hi guys, How many articles would say it would take to begin with and to grab the attention of readers for a starting blog?.
  • Response
    see here for best information on a forever recovery methods around
  • Response
    Response: webpage
    can any post on a personal blog (with disclaimer that it is his personal view) be used by any brand for filing a case against an individual for 'brand tarnishing' etc?.
  • Response
    Response: PSN gift card
    What is a good free blogging website that I can respond to blogs and others will respond to me?
  • Response
    see here for best marketing online madrid available
  • Response
    Response: Howard Wilner
    I want to start a website for my Roller derby team, all we have is a myspace right now. How can I start a website that has a dot com, or html, etc, that I can design on my own, and keep up on my own so that we can actually ...
  • Response
    see here for greatest experto en seo around
  • Response
    What makes a computer choosing random numbers, start at 3, or 5, or 3027846?
  • Response
    Response: sydney.net
    click here for best sydney business around

Reader Comments

There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>